A Brazilian federal deputy’s push to force licensed betting operators to refund all customer losses has triggered fierce legal opposition, with experts warning of billion-reais consequences.
Udo Seckelmann, a partner at Bichara e Motta Advogados, wasted no time in branding the proposal “a genuine legal aberration” after it surfaced in the Chamber of Deputies.
The bill in question, PL No. 5,502/2026, was submitted by Federal Deputy Ricardo Abrão (PSDB-RJ) and carries the title “Full Restitution and Compensation for Bettors Law.”
Referred on 12 November to both the Consumer Protection Committee and the Constitution, Justice and Citizenship Committee, the proposal now faces formal parliamentary scrutiny from two separate bodies.
Its scope is sweeping, listing 10 categories of reimbursable harm including net account losses, unreturned balances, unpaid winnings, cancelled bets, and unauthorised transactions.
Operators would also be required to furnish customers with “detailed transaction statements within 10 working days,” a timeline Seckelmann described as operationally unworkable at any meaningful scale.
Seckelmann was blunt about the financial stakes, warning that “operators could be required to reimburse billions of reais in losses accumulated by bettors, creating an unpredictable and potentially unpayable liability.”
He drew a firm line between legitimate accountability and what Abrão’s bill demands, stating: “Holding companies accountable for fraud, operational failures or breaches of contract is one thing; turning legitimate losses into an obligation to reimburse is something entirely different.”
The bill emerged against a turbulent regulatory backdrop, with President Lula having issued a ban on online gambling through provisional measure No. 1,394/2026 on 25 September 2026.
Justice Luiz Fux of the Supreme Federal Court subsequently suspended lower-court proceedings challenging that ban, leaving the sector’s fate caught between the STF and Congress simultaneously.
Abrão cited Lula’s provisional measure as the legal opening for his refund proposal, arguing it made consumer restitution not only justified but applicable under the current suspension of operations.
“The urgency and relevance of this proposal are grounded in the situation following the suspension of operations,” the deputy stated in the bill’s formal submission to the Chamber.
Abrão positioned the legislation as a matter of fairness, arguing operators and their controlling shareholders should bear all costs, with no financial burden falling on taxpayers.
He framed the broader justification in terms of market failures, characterising licensed platforms as participants in the “unchecked expansion of a market that has harmed vulnerable Brazilians, making repayment of customers’ losses necessary.”
Seckelmann countered that the bill fundamentally misunderstands the nature of gambling contracts, adding: “The proposal subverts the legal rationale underpinning betting, undermines legal certainty and disregards the inherently uncertain nature of betting contracts.”
He acknowledged that political momentum against the sector could carry the bill forward, but predicted it would collide with constitutional barriers around proportionality, freedom of enterprise, and the protection of validly concluded legal acts.
His closing assessment left little room for ambiguity: “Consumer protection cannot serve as justification for creating arbitrary financial obligations or disregarding the nature of lawfully concluded contracts. If approved in its current form, the bill will certainly be challenged in court.”

